Nelson Co. Families Fighting Pipeline LawsuitPosted: Updated: Feb 06, 2015 03:27 PM
Landowners in Nelson County are pushing back against Atlantic Coast Pipeline LLC for trying to survey their land for the Dominion natural gas pipeline.
Dominion is partnering with other utilities to build the $5 billion Atlantic Coast Pipeline, which would cross the Blue Ridge Mountains to deliver gas from Pennsylvania, Ohio and West Virginia.
Five Nelson Co. couples are filing motions to dismiss a lawsuit from ACP. The company is suing landowners who won't give them permission to survey their land for the pipeline project.
Landowners say Dominion sent notices to survey their land, but ACP did not. Therefore, they argue ACP doesn't have the right to sue them.
“There are many, many impacts that this pipeline will have, not just to our particular piece of land but to the county in general,” said Corry Andrews, Nelson Co. landowner. "We feel very comfortable fighting it legally, and with any means that we can at this point.”
Landowners also say the survey statute is unconstitutional because it allows for taking private property without providing any compensation.
The Associated Press contributed to this article.
Press release from Friends of Nelson County:
Michael Derdeyn, of Lenhart Pettit, PC, has filed in the Nelson Circuit Court a motion to dismiss Atlantic Coast Pipeline, LLC's lawsuits to force entry onto the property of certain Nelson landowners in order to survey for a high-pressure, 42” natural gas pipeline. The lawsuits rely on a Virginia statute purporting to allow such entry by a gas company after the company has given landowners certain notices.
After Dominion spokesman Jim Norvelle first announced the lawsuits on Christmas Eve, the Nelson community quickly organized to support affected landowners and to respond to protect their property rights. On January 3rd, one pipeline-fighting group, Free Nelson, organized a well-attended “Ban the Grinch” party for landowners and community members to celebrate Nelson's strong community spirit and provide a forum to share resources.
Friends of Nelson, a separate group also fighting the pipeline in Nelson, quickly started a Landowner Defense fund and began considering legal options. Friends of Nelson retained Mr. Derdeyn to represent some of the first landowners to be served, to set a positive precedent for all the similar suits that would follow.
Yesterday Mr. Derdeyn filed demurrers (motions to dismiss) on behalf of five couples in Nelson County. He urges the court to dismiss on two separate bases.
First, Atlantic Coast Pipeline (ACP), which has brought the suits, has no right under the statute to access landowner property because ACP never sent any notices as required by the statute. Instead, only the wholly separate corporation of Dominion Transmission sent notices, and Dominion, if it has any right to enter under the statute, cannot under Virginia law transfer that right to another company. Accordingly, ACP lacks “standing.”
Second, the survey statute is unconstitutional under the Virginia constitution, because it allows a "taking" of private property, meaning the loss of the property owner's exclusive use, but doesn't provide any compensation for this taking.
ACP has yet to complete serving its suit on all of its sued landowners in Nelson, and has withdrawn the suit in at least three cases due to route confusion.